Direct answer
Do an SEO audit by working in order: record your baseline in Search Console, check which pages Google has indexed, crawl the site for errors, test speed and mobile, review titles and content page by page, then check links and local signals. Finish with a list of fixes ranked by impact and effort, and fix the biggest ones first.
What is an SEO audit, and what is it not?
An SEO audit is a health check for your website. It tells you what is stopping your site from performing as well as it could in search, and what to fix first. It covers four broad areas: whether Google can find and read your site, whether it understands what each page is about, whether it trusts your site, and whether your pages answer what your customers are looking for, per crawllexa.com.
An audit is not a guarantee of rankings, and it is not a one-off fix that solves everything forever, per dpom.co.uk. It is also not a list of 200 errors in red. A crawler can produce hundreds of warnings on a perfectly healthy site, per crawllexa.com. The useful output is a short, prioritised list of what to fix, in what order, and why. An audit is only useful if it ends in a short action plan. A 90-page report that nobody acts on is worth nothing, per dpom.co.uk.
Most small business sites have never had a proper audit. In a 2026 Small Business Expo survey, 55.6 percent of small businesses said they do not invest in SEO at all, per thryv.com. That is the opportunity: a site that has never been checked usually has two or three real problems hiding in plain sight, and fixing them is often free.
What free tools do you need?
You do not need expensive software for a first audit. These free tools cover most of what a small business site needs, per dpom.co.uk.
| Tool | What it tells you | Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Google Search Console | Which pages are indexed, what searches bring visits, crawl errors, Core Web Vitals, manual actions | Free |
| Screaming Frog SEO Spider | Crawls your site like Google does: broken links, redirects, missing titles, duplicate content | Free up to 500 URLs |
| PageSpeed Insights | Speed on mobile and desktop, plus Core Web Vitals results | Free |
| Google Analytics 4 | Which visits end in an enquiry or a sale, and which pages earn them | Free |
| Google Business Profile | How your business appears in local search and Maps | Free |
Screaming Frog’s free version crawls up to 500 URLs, which covers most small business sites, per dpom.co.uk. Google Search Console is the single most important tool in the list. It shows which pages are indexed, what searches you appear for, crawl errors, Core Web Vitals and any manual actions, per dpom.co.uk. Set up Search Console first if you have not already. Everything else builds from it.
Before you touch anything, write down how the website is doing today: clicks, impressions and enquiries for the last three months, per raulburgos.com. That baseline is what you compare against after the fixes, so you know whether the work helped.
Step 1: Record a baseline first
Start with data, not a crawler, per crawllexa.com. Open Search Console and open the Performance report. Sort the pages by clicks and note down your top ten pages, your total clicks and impressions for the last three months, and the searches that bring the most visits. Note the pages that should earn traffic but do not. Those pages get audited first, per crawllexa.com.
Then check Google Analytics 4, if it is set up, and note which pages lead to enquiries or sales. A page that gets visits but no enquiries has a different problem from a page that gets no visits at all, and the audit should treat them differently. For the full routine on reading these reports, read our guide on how to measure SEO results in Google Search Console for beginners. It shows where each number lives and what a normal result looks like.
Write the baseline numbers in a simple sheet: page, clicks, impressions, enquiries. You will use this sheet again in Step 9, when you decide what to fix first.
Step 2: Check what Google has indexed
If Google has not indexed a page, it cannot rank. Open Search Console, open the Pages report under Indexing, and look at how many pages are indexed and the list of reasons others are not, per dpom.co.uk. Common reasons include pages blocked by robots.txt, pages marked noindex, duplicate pages that Google chose not to index, and pages Google has found but not yet crawled.
Rule out emergencies before anything else: manual actions, security issues, robots.txt blocks, a stray noindex tag, or a server that fails for crawlers, per crawllexa.com. These are rare, but they sit at the top of the priority list when they appear, because nothing else matters until they are fixed. Search Console shows manual actions and security issues directly, so check those screens first and move on if they are clear.
Then compare your indexed pages with the pages you actually want to rank. A site with 50 pages in its sitemap but only 30 indexed has 20 pages to investigate. Note which important pages are missing, and whether the missing ones are pages you care about or pages that should never have been indexed in the first place, such as tag pages, thin archive pages or old test pages.
Step 3: Crawl the site and compare three lists
Run Screaming Frog on your site. The free version covers up to 500 URLs, per raulburgos.com. The crawl finds broken links, redirects, missing titles and duplicate content, per dpom.co.uk. Then compare three lists: what the crawler finds, what your sitemap claims, and what Search Console says is indexed. The gaps between them are where most technical problems hide, per crawllexa.com.
A page the crawler finds but the sitemap does not list may be an orphan page with no internal links pointing to it. A page in the sitemap that the crawler cannot reach may be blocked or broken. A page Search Console says is indexed but the crawler cannot find may have been removed without a redirect. Each gap is a finding. Write each one down with the page address, so the action list at the end names real pages, not vague problems.
Do not chase every warning the crawler shows. Most tool warnings do not matter. Google says third-party tools do not have access to its internal ranking data, so check a tool’s recommendations against official guidance before you act on them, per crawllexa.com. A warning on a page nobody visits and Google does not index is not a priority. A broken link on your most visited service page is.
Step 4: Test speed and mobile
Run your homepage and one key service page through PageSpeed Insights. It shows a simulated lab result and, when Google has enough data, results from real visitors, per effektivweb.com. Check mobile results first, because most of your visitors are on phones. Google judges Core Web Vitals on field data at the 75th percentile, which means at least three in four visits need to be good, per effektivweb.com.
The three targets are: Largest Contentful Paint within 2.5 seconds, Interaction to Next Paint within 200 milliseconds, and Cumulative Layout Shift under 0.1, per effektivweb.com. Record the numbers for each page you test. A page that fails all three has a speed problem worth fixing before you touch its content. A page that passes all three does not need speed work, whatever the audit tool says about it.
For the fixes themselves, read our guide on how to improve website speed for SEO on WordPress. It works through hosting, caching, images, plugins and scripts in the order that matters, so you fix the actual bottleneck instead of guessing. Only 43 percent of WordPress origins pass all three Core Web Vitals on mobile, according to Chrome User Experience Report data from late 2025, per wppoland.com. You do not need to be perfect. You need to be in the half that passes.
Step 5: Check structure and internal links
A page with no internal links pointing to it is called an orphan page. It may still appear in your sitemap, but a sitemap alone is weaker than a real link from a related page. Google finds most new pages by following links, and a page buried four or five clicks from the home page tends to be crawled less often and to perform worse.
Check the structure with a simple rule: every important page should sit two or three clicks from the home page. Start at the home page and count the clicks to each service page and each key blog post. Then check that each blog post links back up to the service page it supports, and that each service page links down to the posts that support it. Link each orphan from a related hub page and one related post.
Also check your anchor text, the visible clickable words of each link. Good anchor text names the destination in plain words. Avoid “click here” and “read more” on their own, because they say nothing about the destination. Avoid repeating the exact same anchor text on every page.
Step 6: Review titles, meta descriptions and content page by page
Work through your important pages one at a time, starting with the pages that earn the most clicks in your baseline sheet. For each page, check four things: the title, the meta description, the main heading, and whether the content answers the search it ranks for.
The title should name the page’s topic in plain words and stay under 60 characters, so it is not cut off in search results. The meta description should describe the page in one or two sentences and stay under 160 characters. The page should have exactly one H1 heading, and it should match the title closely. If two pages target the same search, they compete with each other, and one of them should be changed or merged.
Then read the content as a customer would. Does the page answer the question the visitor arrived with? Does it say what the business does, where it does it, and what the visitor should do next? Thin pages with a few sentences and no useful detail are a common audit finding. So are pages that were written for search engines years ago and now read like keyword lists. Note each one, and whether it needs new content, a merge with a related page, or removal.
Step 7: Decide what each page should do
Content is half the audit. Every page should earn its place: keep it, improve it, merge it or retire it, based on what it does for searchers, per crawllexa.com. This is the step most audits skip, and it is the step that saves the most work, because a site with fewer, better pages is easier to maintain and easier for Google to understand.
Sort your pages into four groups. Keep the pages that earn visits or enquiries and answer their topic well. Improve the pages that rank but could rank better with more detail, better examples or clearer structure. Merge the pages that overlap each other into one stronger page, and redirect the old address to the new one. Retire the pages that serve nobody: old offers, test pages, duplicate pages with no visits. For a retired page that had links or visits, add a redirect to the closest live page. For a page with nothing pointing to it, removal is fine.
Be honest about your own pages. A page you wrote two years ago for a service you no longer offer is not an asset. Removing it, or merging it into a current page, is a fix, not a loss.
Step 8: Check links and local signals
First, the links pointing to your site. Search Console shows them in the Links report: which sites link to you, and which of your pages they link to. You do not need hundreds of links. You need to know whether the links you have are real and relevant, and whether any important page has none at all. A service page with no links pointing to it from anywhere, inside or outside your site, is a page Google has little reason to trust.
Then, if you serve local customers, check your Google Business Profile. Is the business name, address and phone number exactly the same as on your website? Are the opening hours current? Are there recent reviews, and have you replied to them? Inconsistent business details across your website and online listings are a common audit finding, per thryv.com, and they cost local visibility. Check that your business details match on your website and across online listings, per thryv.com.
Finally, search for your business name and your main service plus your town, in Google and in an AI answer tool, and see whether your business shows up. Showing up in AI answers is called answer engine optimisation, and this check shows whether your business is visible where customers now ask questions, per thryv.com.
Step 9: Turn the findings into a short action plan
Detail means every finding is tied to evidence and to the pages that matter: which URLs are affected, how much traffic they carry, what the fix is, and how you will know it worked, per crawllexa.com. Prioritise by impact, effort and page value, per crawllexa.com. A fix that takes ten minutes and helps your most visited page comes before a fix that takes a day and helps a page nobody visits.
| Priority | What it looks like | Example fix |
|---|---|---|
| Fix first | Blocks Google or visitors: not indexed, server error, manual action, broken checkout | Restore the page, fix the server error, clear the manual action |
| Fix soon | Hurts your best pages: slow service page, missing title, orphan service page | Speed up the page, write the title, add internal links |
| Fix later | Nice to have: thin old blog post, minor duplicate, low value page | Expand, merge or retire the page |
| Ignore | Warning on a page with no visits and no links | Leave it, and note why |
Write the plan as a short table: the problem, the page, why it matters, what the fix is, and who will do it and when. Keep it to one page. A basic review of a small website takes a few hours, per raulburgos.com. A complete audit with competitors, content and priorities takes between two and four weeks depending on the size of the site, per raulburgos.com. Your plan should match the time you actually have.
For the fixes themselves, work through our technical SEO checklist for WordPress beginners. It covers the same ground as this audit, one fix at a time, in plain English, so the audit tells you what is wrong and the checklist tells you how to fix it.
How often should you audit your site?
For most small businesses, a thorough audit once a year is sensible, with lighter monthly checks in between: a quick look at Search Console for new indexing errors, a scan of traffic trends and a check of your Google Business Profile, per dpom.co.uk. Some guides suggest quarterly audits at minimum, per launchnorth.com.au. Either rhythm works, as long as it happens. The audit that never runs finds nothing.
| Check | How often | What to look at |
|---|---|---|
| Search Console errors | Monthly | New indexing errors, coverage drops, manual actions |
| Traffic trends | Monthly | Clicks and impressions vs last month, top pages |
| Google Business Profile | Monthly | Hours, reviews, replies, business details |
| Full audit | Once a year | All nine steps in this guide, top to bottom |
| After a big change | As needed | New design, new host, migration, big content change |
Run a fresh audit after any big change: a new design, a new host, a site migration, or a large content change. Those are the moments when new problems appear, and catching them in the first week is far cheaper than finding them six months later.
Frequently asked questions
How long does an SEO audit take?
A basic review of a small website takes a few hours, per raulburgos.com. A complete audit, with competitors, content and priorities, takes between two and four weeks depending on the size of the site, per raulburgos.com. Start with the free tools in this guide and work through the steps in order.
Do I need paid tools to audit my website?
No. You can do a solid first audit yourself with free tools: Google Search Console, Google Analytics, PageSpeed Insights and a crawler such as Screaming Frog, per dpom.co.uk. Paid tools help with competitor research and large sites, but they are not needed for a first audit of a small business site.
How often should I audit my website?
A thorough audit once a year is sensible, with lighter monthly checks in between, per dpom.co.uk. Run a fresh audit after any big change, such as a new design, a new host or a migration.
What is the first thing to check in an SEO audit?
Rule out emergencies first: manual actions, security issues, robots.txt blocks, a stray noindex tag, or a server that fails for crawlers, per crawllexa.com. Then record your baseline in Search Console, so every finding after that is measured against real numbers.
Can I audit my own website?
Yes. You can handle many SEO fixes yourself, per thryv.com. Consider outside help when technical or ongoing SEO work takes more time or expertise than you want to give it, per thryv.com. Google’s own advice on hiring an SEO sets the same bar: an audit should give you realistic estimates of improvement and an estimate of the work involved, per crawllexa.com.
What should an SEO audit report contain?
A summary, evidence, priorities, owners and a roadmap, not a PDF of warnings, per crawllexa.com. Each finding should name the affected pages, how much traffic they carry, what the fix is, who does it, and how you will know it worked.
Conclusion
An SEO audit is a health check, not a chore. Work through it in order: baseline, indexing, crawl, speed, structure, on-page, content decisions, links and local signals, then a short action plan ranked by impact and effort. Use free tools, write down real page addresses, and fix the biggest problems first. A small site audited once a year, with light monthly checks in between, stays ahead of most competitors, because most small business sites are never checked at all. That is the whole job, and it costs nothing but a few hours of your time.

